Tax season guide · Updated November 11, 2026
Form 8879 e-signature with KBA: IRS rules, costs and software compared
Clients want to sign from the couch, not drive to your office. Here is what the IRS requires before a remote Form 8879 e-signature, how knowledge-based authentication works, and what it really costs, subscription included, in BytesHood, TaxDome, Canopy and Karbon.
Disclosure: BytesHood, LLC publishes this guide and sells one of the products compared. IRS information comes from the IRS’s e-file signature FAQ; competitor prices come from each vendor’s official help pages, reviewed November 11, 2026. This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Prices change; confirm them with each vendor.
What the IRS requires for a remote Form 8879 signature
The IRS calls it a remote transaction when the taxpayer signs electronically and the electronic return originator (ERO) is not physically present. A scanned or faxed handwritten signature is not a remote transaction; it is still a handwritten signature. [1]
For a remote e-signature on Form 8879 or 8878, the ERO’s software has to verify the taxpayer’s identity before they sign. In practice, that means KBA:
| Requirement | What it means for your firm |
|---|---|
| Identity verification | The taxpayer answers multiple-choice questions about their personal and financial history. The IRS notes this is not a credit check. |
| Every time | Verification is repeated each time a taxpayer e-signs, with two narrow exceptions described in the IRS FAQ. |
| Three attempts | If the taxpayer fails after three attempts, the ERO must get a handwritten signature. |
| Signature record | A digital image of the signed form, the date and time of the signature, the taxpayer’s IP address and login user name, the result of the identity check, and the e-signature method used. |
| Retention | Kept in a secure, access-controlled storage system for three years. |
Summarized from the IRS’s “Frequently asked questions for IRS e-file signature authorization” (page last reviewed June 27, 2026) and IRS Publication 1345. Read the current IRS guidance for the full rules and exceptions.
How KBA works for your client
From the client’s side, it takes a few minutes and happens right in the portal where they already receive their documents. In BytesHood it looks like this:
- Open the signature request. The client signs in to your firm’s portal with a one-time code and opens Form 8879.
- Enter their details. Name, Social Security number, date of birth and address go straight to the identity-verification service. They are not stored in your firm’s system.
- Answer a few questions. The service checks the details against public records and credit-bureau data, then asks questions such as which of several streets the client has lived on.
- Sign. Once identity is confirmed, the client adopts a signature and signs. The result of the check is recorded on the document’s audit trail.
On a joint return, each spouse goes through KBA separately and signs their own part, so a half-signed form is easy to spot. If a client can’t pass after three tries, the form can’t be signed in the portal and your office is told to collect a hand signature, matching the IRS rule.
What KBA costs in BytesHood
KBA is optional and paid only when your clients use it. There is nothing else to buy or set up.
| How you pay | Price | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Prepaid credit | $1.50 per quiz | Bought in BHAPS, $15 or more at a time |
| Pay as you go | $2 per quiz | Billed monthly to the card on your subscription |
Each try is a new quiz, up to three per signer, and each spouse on a joint return gets their own. Nothing is charged when a signer’s details don’t match the records and no quiz is given. Your plan price and unlimited clients do not change.
Every platform charges KBA on top of a subscription that is many times larger, and that is where the real difference is.
The real comparison: subscription plus KBA
Take a three-person tax firm with 250 active clients that sends 150 remote Form 8879s in a season, 60 of them joint returns. That is 210 signer verifications. We first assume every client passes on the first attempt, then show what retries add.
| Platform | Subscription | KBA | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| BytesHood Firm, first year | $800 | $315 (prepaid) | $1,115 |
| BytesHood Firm, years after | $1,000 | $315 (prepaid) | $1,315 |
| TaxDome, 250 active accounts | $2,700 | $210 | $2,910 |
| Canopy Standard, 3 users | $2,664 | $262.50 | $2,926.50 |
| Karbon Team, 3 users | $2,124 | 630 e-signature credits | $2,124 + credits |
Annual billing. TaxDome: calculator result for 250 active accounts captured November 2, 2026 [6], plus $1 per attempt [2]; any failed attempt adds another $1. Canopy: $74 per user per month billed annually [7] plus $1.25 per credit [3]. Karbon: $59 per user per month paid annually [8]; KBA uses 3 e-signature credits per signer [4], priced by plan. BytesHood: Firm plan with 3 staff seats and unlimited clients [5]; pay-as-you-go KBA would be $420 instead of $315; each retry is another quiz at $1.50 ($2 pay as you go). Excludes taxes, add-ons and payment fees.
What if clients need a second or third try?
Each try in BytesHood is a new quiz. Here is the same firm when some clients, or all of them, need another try:
| Platform | Everyone passes first time | 1 in 10 needs a second try | Every signer uses every try |
|---|---|---|---|
| BytesHood Firm, prepaid KBA | $1,115 | $1,146.50 | $1,745 (630 quizzes) |
| TaxDome, 250 active accounts | $2,910 | $2,931 | $3,120 (420 attempts) |
| Canopy Standard, 3 users | $2,926.50 | $2,926.50 | $2,926.50 |
BytesHood allows three tries and TaxDome two; Canopy charges one credit per signature. The last column is a worst case, not a forecast: most clients pass the first time. Even then, BytesHood’s first year costs about $1,180 less than Canopy and $1,375 less than TaxDome.
That is $1,795 less than TaxDome and $1,811.50 less than Canopy, with remote Form 8879 signing and KBA included in the total. Grow to 500 clients and TaxDome’s subscription alone rises to $5,175 a year; BytesHood’s stays the same, because every plan has unlimited clients.
Subscription and KBA fee comparison under the stated assumptions; not a claim of identical features.
Why tax firms choose BytesHood for remote 8879 signing
- KBA is part of the portal, not a bolt-on. Clients sign in, verify and sign in one place, in English or about 20 other languages for the portal itself.
- Every signer verified. Both spouses on a joint return confirm their own identity, and each signature shows its own status.
- Sensitive details stay out of your system. The Social Security number and date of birth go straight to the verification service; your firm keeps the result, on the audit trail.
- Three tries, then a clear handoff. The portal follows the IRS three-attempt rule, one more try than TaxDome gives, and tells your office when a hand signature is needed.
- A price that doesn’t grow with your client list. Unlimited clients on every plan, so busy season never means a bigger bill.
- More than e-signatures. The same subscription includes Client Management, Payroll Tax Manager, Sales Tax Manager, Billing & Payment and Tax Notice Manager.
- Easy to move in. Move in reads exports from TaxDome, Canopy, Karbon, Financial Cents, HoneyBook and ATOM, so you can switch before the season starts.
Checklist: questions to ask any KBA vendor
- Is KBA built into the client portal, or a separate e-signature tool your clients must learn?
- Is each spouse verified separately on a joint return?
- How many attempts does a client get, and what happens after the last one?
- Are you charged when a client’s details don’t match the records and no questions are asked?
- Where are the Social Security number and date of birth stored, if at all?
- Does the audit trail show the identity check result with the signed form, ready to hand over if the IRS asks?
- What does the whole bill look like at your client count, subscription included?
Helping clients pass KBA the first time
Most KBA failures come from details that don’t match the records. Before sending Form 8879, confirm the client’s legal name and current address, and suggest they sign when they have a few quiet minutes. Questions can cover older addresses and past loans, so a client who moved recently may want their previous address handy. A first-time pass also keeps the fee down, since each try is charged. And keep a hand-signature path ready for the few who can’t pass.
Book a personal walkthrough and we’ll show you the whole path, from sending the form to a signed 8879 with the identity result on the audit trail. Pick a time or read how it works.

